Showing posts with label game of thrones. Show all posts
Showing posts with label game of thrones. Show all posts

Sunday, August 18, 2013

PPOM - If You Don't Love Sansa Stark You Are Wrong


If you don’t love Sansa Stark, you are wrong, and I’m about to tell you why.
 


If you don’t watch or read Game of Thrones/A Song of Ice and Fire, the depths of your wrongness know no bounds, and you should probably stop reading this and start reading/watching that. But even if you don’t know who the hell she is, you should love Sansa Stark anyway, and like I said, I’ma tell you why.

People don’t like Sansa because she’s whiney, apparently, and because she is naïve. And I admit, Sansa does spend a lot of time waiting for someone to rescue her, and gets pretty damn weepy every time something goes wrong. But let’s look at the facts for a second.

·      Sansa is the first born female Stark, she was raised to be a princess, and raised for marriage and babies.
·      Sansa is beautiful.
·      She has spent her whole childhood in Winterfell, which is about as isolated and removed from reality as you can get this side of the wall.
·      The adults in Sansa’s life wanted her to be innocent and uneducated, whether they knew that’s what they were doing or not.
·      Sansa has always defined herself in opposition to her tomboy sister, Arya.
·      She *likes* sweet things likes songs and cakes and flowers… is that so surprising or bad?
·      They killed her dad in front of her, and then made her stay in King’s Landing with his murderers.
·      Joffrey is a massive dick.
·      They beat her, publicly stripped her and psychologically messed with her.
·      She had no one.
·      And no one came to rescue her.
·      People who promised to rescue her didn’t.
·      They killed her brother, her mother, and basically the entire court/guard of Winterfell.
·      And still no one came for her.
·      They married her into the family of people who ruined her life.
·      She is 13 years old.

So um… your argument is invalid. Basically, of all the main POV characters, I think Sansa has it the hardest for the longest. She’s not allowed to whinge about it?

Also, she survives. If Arya were in Sansa’s situation, I feel like she’d be dead. There is no way Arya would have held her tongue, played the “little dove” and survived. She would have tried to do something valiant and badass, and they would have killed her for it. But sometime after Ned’s death, something in Sansa flips, and she suddenly knows what it is she has to do. Uneducated and silly, foolish little Sansa realises that they need her alive, and that they need her to play along. So she does. She says what they want her to say, goes through the motions, acts heartbroken when they void her engagement to King Dickface and survives.

 “Lady Stark you may survive us yet” – the cleverest person in the room.

Sansa plays the game of thrones like a girl, and by that I mean she doesn’t rely on traditionally masculine traits to survive. Characters like Brienne, Arya and (to an extent) Daenerys have to eschew femininity to get through life. Now don’t get me wrong, I just listed three of my favourite characters, and there’s nothing I love more than a badass Arya moment, or a Brienne-is-the-best- at-everything swordfight, but there are other ways to be strong: in A Song of Ice and Fire... Sansa is a lipstick feminist.

Sansa does everything with grace and poise; she is elegant, beautiful and dainty. She is clever, and wary, and learns how to start guarding herself and reserving her trust. The Tyrells have to work very hard to win her over, and even then Sansa understands that they need her too, and that she is just a piece in other people’s games. Moreover, when they decide to marry her off, not to pretty, valiant Loras, but to the unknown, crippled Willas*, she decides that she’ll be a good wife, name her kids after her siblings, and notes that people will probably stop trying to beat and kill her all the time. In short, she has learnt how to play the game in order to survive.

*non-book readers, in the books it’s not explicitly mentioned that Loras is gay, really, and while Sansa has a bit of a moment thinking she’ll get to marry him, this storyline is significantly different.


***** Spoilers follow for those who haven’t read the books, scroll to the stars if you don’t want them****



I have a theory that Sansa is going to become a major player very soon, and if you want evidence for it, all you have to do is look at how much she changes once she leaves King’s Landing. As she plays the part of Petyr’s bastard daughter, she becomes more and more savvy. She picks up on who is in his pay and who isn’t, understands that all is not always as it seems, and recognises that Petyr’s conniving wisdom is probably what she needs now to survive. All the while, she continues to play it like a lady. She hides how she truly feels about irritating little Robert and her Aunt Lysa, and knows she must continue to play a certain part.

I think she is going to learn a lot under Petyr’s tutelage, but that she will be strong enough in her own convictions to become her own kind of player, no longer simply a pawn. I can’t ever see her wanting to go back to King’s Landing, but we may well see a Queen in the North sometime soon, and I tell you what, I’ll be bending the knee.





***********Spoilers are over now, it’s ok*************



Basically, Sansa is no badass, she’s not a hero, and she isn’t ever going to stop loving lemon cakes, but that doesn’t make her a bad character and it doesn’t make her unlovable. She’s the best, basically, and she does everything like a girl. A clever, awesome, wonderful girl. If you don’t like Sansa, you’re wrong, and if I haven’t yet convinced you, I’ll leave you with a few more things…

“All you need to know about Sansa in this book is that she has a direwolf – a giant, monstrous wolf, a half-mythological monster, a killing machine – and she names it Lady.” – Schmoop

“My skin has turned to porcelain, to ivory, to steel.” – Sansa Stark

Sansa’s hair is amazing. And has really interesting meanings. You can track Sansa’s loyalty and emotions by how she does her hair, and I just think that is amazing.












Finally, you should know that Sophie Turner, who plays Sansa in the show, adopted the dog that played Lady, because like Sansa, Sophie is amazing.









August is Potentially Problematic Opinions Month. Led by Alex from Adventures in TV-Land, a bunch of bloggers will tell you about opinions they hold that might piss you off, or make you think, or be so obvious you can’t believe anyone would think them problematic, opening your eyes to a whole world of people who don’t agree with you. This is my description, by the way, and it’s possible that Alex has a completely different one. Ooooooh Potentially Problematic!

What else is happening in PPOM? (will be updated with links as they happen)

Noni has joined us! With an absolutely amazing post entitled "I'm fat. That's ok". 

Alex tells us she is actually thinking about voting for Clive Palmer, and what that says about political discourse in Australia right now. 

Sunday, July 7, 2013

Loving the Problematic


I am, as you probably know by now, a consumer of media. I devour books, I mass watch TV shows, I obsess about things that “aren’t real”. This means I’ve read and watched a lot of good things in my time, but it also means I’ve encountered a lot of shit things too. Especially because, no matter how crappy something is, I will usually finish it. I persevered, for example, with four whole seasons of Smallville before final giving it up in frustration. I read the entire Twilight series in the vain hope that the writing might get better, or perhaps that the damage it was causing to my brain might lower my expectations.

As you also know from my ranting, and my overanalysis of such media, I am a feminist, and I believe in equality of all people regardless of race, culture, gender identity or sexuality. Unfortunately, most of the media I consume does not think like this. Most of the media I consume believes that “sex sells”, that putting women in revealing outfits means they are just “giving the people what they want”, that gay guys are funny, that Asian people all sound the same, that white, middle class, athletic American dudes are the “everyman” that we can all identify with. In short, media is a bit shit. Books are a bit shit. Stuff I enjoy is a bit shit.

So how can I justify this to myself? Well… by writing a blog about it and trying to make it ok, I guess is one way to look at it. The answer is, I can’t really. It’s important to me that I recognise that the last scene in the most recent Game of Thrones season has a problematic depiction of people of colour, that Sherlock doesn’t pass the Bechdel Test, that Cho Chang from Harry Potter has a name that is actually two last names from the wrong culture. It’s important for me to register those things in my brain. And it’s important for me to discuss these things with other people, to talk about why they are problematic, to write blogs about them, because I think those are discussions worth having.

And yet… I still enjoy the books and TV that contain these problematic elements. How can that be? How can I reconcile myself with these things? Sometimes I worry it makes me a bad feminist or even just a bad person to consume some of the media I consume. Doctor Who for example, is pretty much all out hated by feminists these days. And I can, for the most part, understand why. But I don’t hate it. Yes I groan at certain parts, yes it shits me at times, but I still watch and enjoy it. It’s still a really good show. I like it for all the things that don’t shit me, for the amazing stories, for the silliness, for the drama, the music and the sets. I like it for Clara and for River and for Rory and for history and aliens.

Probably my worst crime of the problematic at the moment is Supernatural. I just marathoned all eight seasons of that thing. And holy freaking shit it’s the most misogynistic piece of crap I’ve watched in a long time. Women are killed every few minutes, one of the main characters uses the words, “bitch”, “whore”, “slut” etc. to describe pretty much every woman they come into contact with, and the series of sexual encounters of both Dean and Sam are described like conquests all the time. But I still liked the show. HOW IS THIS POSSIBLE? I’m not even sure. Yes, I would definitely enjoy it more if I didn’t spend large portions of the viewing experience with my fists on my forehead in what I like to call the “god damn it misogyny!” pose, but I didn’t hate the show. It has action and fighting and comedy and good characters and ghosts and vampires and angels and increasingly, Felicia Day. I am in fact looking forward to the 9th season.

So what am I saying? I guess… that we live in a problematic world, and our media reflects this? It’s nigh on impossible to find a book, TV show, movie, comic etc. that doesn’t have problematic elements. It doesn’t mean we should accept it as “normal”, it doesn’t mean we shouldn’t be angry, or frustrated, it doesn’t mean we shouldn’t have discussions about how the things we love could be better but it doesn’t mean we can’t love those problematic things. In fact, I would argue that loving these things means there’s a better chance of them getting better.

I think there’s something to be said for being a discerning audience member, an involved reader. Watch and read what you like, but do so cleverly, do so with nous. Because it’s intelligent discussion and discerning analysis that bring about change, just as much as revolution and boycott. If something offends you, switch it off, if you want, but if something is problematic but still enjoyable, keep watching. Register the problematic elements, talk about them, blog about them, write to the writers, make a video. Say “I love ______, but it worries me that the following things keep happening”. The show runners and writers aren’t going to change their product for the people who turn it off; they are going to change it for the people who keep watching, for the people who keep reading…. For us. 

The "Goddamn it Misogyny!" face, copyright L. King 2013

Monday, April 15, 2013

Why Everyone should be Watching Game of Thrones


Everyone should be watching Game of Thrones: A Year 9-style Persuasive Essay

By Lizzy King

Everyone should be watching Game of Thrones because it is really well made, has seriously good actors and appeals to every kind of viewer. Lots of people already watch Game of Thrones, suggesting that it is pretty good, but if you are not one of those people, this essay aims to persuade you that you should be.

Game of Thrones is really well made. It’s made by HBO, who are really good at all things. If HBO had to perform brain surgery, they could totally do it. They would research brain surgery to excruciating detail, design surgeon costumes more realistic than actual surgeon’s outfits and score it with the most bad-ass music you’ve ever heard. They would also be the best brain surgeon in the world. Game of Thrones is based on a series of books, but rather than following the trend of most book to screen adaptations (the old slap dash, nah the fans won’t notice if we completely change everything technique), HBO does an astonishingly good job of making adaptive changes where necessary (lol George RR Marting almost certainly can’t remember all of his characters or places - seriously those books are DENSE) while still keeping the show true to the books in a really satisfying way. Game of Thrones is the ONLY book to screen adaptation where I am not vehemently in support of reading the books first. The books are good, but if you are a slow reader, or not that great at reading GIANT, DENSE BOOKS with APPENDICES, then seriously just watch the show, it is that good.

Another really excellent thing about Game of Thrones is the casting. First up it has Peter Dinklage in it so don’t even talk to me, that guy is amazing.

Loathed though I am to use a paparazzi shot, this guy makes carrying a baby look bad-ass


 Next it has bad asses like Charles Dance, and Jason Momoa being amazing. 


Regal

This isn't even from Game of Thrones but I googled "Jason Momoa badass" and this showed up so....
They have a lady who is a 6 foot 3 model playing an ugly, sword-wielding hero 

Gwendoline Christie is better than you.

and Natalie Dormer just like politically owning everybody with her brain and her boobs. 

"Booyah! Another win for Margery!"

Most amazing of all, in the first season they cast a whole bunch of children and teenagers in main roles and all of them have grown up to be amazing, attractive, clever, GOOD actors. It is just not possible in any reality I understand for that many child actors to be actually good actors, so obviously they have used some kind of witch-craft.

Perfect humans are perfect.

Thus far I have tried to sell you a show without really telling you what it’s about. Here’s the thing, Game of Thrones has such a broad range of appeal, it’s actually kind of difficult to pinpoint what exactly it is about. But let me at least list a bunch of things that Game of Thrones has in it, to demonstrate that there is not a single person who would not find it in some way appealing. Game of Thrones has sword fighting, battles, strategy, castles, pretty dresses, bizarre hair-dos, dragons, giant wolves that have psychic connections to humans, political intrigue, power play, boobs, bums, penises, sex scenes, flashes of surprise vagina, prostitutes, amazing scenery, comedy, torture, gays, bad asses of all genders, gods, demons, zombies, a giant wall made of ice, wine, beer, history, maps, cool weapons, pirates, sexy horse-riding dudes, sexy cleavage-showing ladies and MUCH MORE.

In conclusion, Game of Thrones is really good. Like, way better than you think it is after watching the first (admittedly pretty confusing) two episodes. Due to its amazing production qualities, brilliant actors and broad range of appeal, it is literally my favourite thing to watch right now, even more than Doctor Who (WOAH I know right, THAT’S HOW GOOD IT IS). If you are already watching it, congratulations, you win all the prizes (including the ability to kill your most hated character and guarantee life for your favourite*). If you are not already watching it, I am confident this essay will have persuaded you to go borrow the first season on DVD.


*Disclaimer: this competition is not a thing, EVERYONE YOU LOVE WILL DIE**

** Non-viewers should leave their trust at the door, EVERYONE YOU LOVE WILL DIE

Bonus reason you should be watching Game of Thrones: this video.